Learn how to identify the signs of a bad workers’ comp lawyer so you can get the representation you deserve and secure maximum benefits
You’ve been injured on the job, the medical bills are piling up, and the future feels uncertain. Workers’ compensation is supposed to be a safety net, but navigating the legalities can feel like another uphill battle.
The good news?
Help is available. Having the right attorney by your side can make a world of difference. But with so much on the line, how do you ensure you’re choosing a lawyer who will truly fight for you?
The reality is that not all workers’ comp attorneys are created equal. So, let’s explore some red flags that could indicate you’re dealing with a subpar attorney who isn’t the best fit for your case.
#1: Your calls and emails aren’t being returned
Responsive communication is crucial in any workers’ comp case. A good workers’ comp lawyer should always keep you informed and address your questions.
If your calls and emails go unanswered for days on end, it shows a concerning lack of communication and respect for your time. This could indicate they’re overloaded, disorganized, or simply not prioritizing your case.
#2: You’re not presented with different options
A good workers’ comp lawyer should explore all settlement possibilities with you. If your lawyer doesn’t explain different options, like pursuing a hearing or considering settlement offers at various stages, it raises a red flag.
They should be guiding you through the process and ensuring you understand all your choices so you’re empowered to make the best decision for your case.
#3: Important deadlines are missed
Missing crucial deadlines is always a serious red flag because it reflects poor organization and a lack of attention to detail, which can jeopardize the success of your case. Missing deadlines for filing claims, submitting evidence, or responding to motions can not only lead to delays but also reductions in workers’ comp benefits or even the dismissal of your case altogether.
If you receive letters or calls directly from the Workers’ Compensation Commission about missed filings or if the benefits you were receiving suddenly stop, it could be a sign that your attorney is missing important workers’ comp deadlines.
This is a serious issue, so don’t hesitate to confront your lawyer and consider seeking new representation if necessary.
What To Expect After Hiring A Workers’ Compensation Lawyer
A detailed overview of the workers’ compensation claims appeals process in North Carolina—from calling an attorney to taking your claim to court.
#4: Your case is passed off to paralegals
If it seems like your case is being passed off to paralegals without proper oversight or communication from your attorney, it could indicate that your attorney isn’t fully invested in your case or is overwhelmed with other responsibilities.
Paralegals play a crucial role in supporting legal work, but the lawyer is ultimately responsible for making critical decisions, formulating strategies, and ensuring the quality of representation. A lawyer who delegates too much or fails to maintain direct involvement might not be providing the personalized attention your case needs.
If you rarely hear from your lawyer directly and your case feels like it’s constantly being passed around, it’s a good idea to talk to your lawyer about your concerns or consider seeking new representation.
#5: There’s high staff turnover at their office
High staff turnover in a workers’ comp lawyer’s office can be a significant sign of a problematic work environment, which can ultimately affect the quality of your representation.
When staff frequently leave, it may suggest issues such as mismanagement, dissatisfaction, or an unhealthy workplace culture. This can disrupt the continuity and consistency of your case handling, as incoming staff members will need time to familiarize themselves with your case and may lack the necessary experience to handle it effectively.
Additionally, frequent staff changes can also lead to a lack of communication and collaboration within the office, resulting in delayed responses, miscommunication, and mistakes in managing your case.
#6: You’re being pressured to accept a quick offer
Being pressured to accept a quick offer could be a bad sign because it often indicates the attorney is prioritizing a fast resolution over your best interests.
Workers’ compensation claims can involve significant complexities, and each case requires careful consideration of the long-term impacts of an injury, medical costs, and potential loss of earnings. A quick settlement might be inadequate to cover all these aspects and could leave you undercompensated.
If your lawyer is pushing for a swift resolution, it could be a sign that they’re more interested in closing your case quickly to collect their fee rather than ensuring you receive the full benefits to which you’re entitled.
A good workers’ comp lawyer will thoroughly evaluate your case, consider all possible damages, and be prepared to fight for the compensation you deserve, even if it takes longer to achieve.
How To Avoid Common Workers’ Comp Insurance Adjuster Tricks
Learn some top tricks used by insurance adjusters and how to avoid them so you can get maximum compensation after an injury.
#7: You’re promised unrealistic outcomes
A workers’ comp lawyer who makes promises that seem too good to be true is likely setting unrealistic expectations, which is a significant red flag. Legal cases, especially workers’ compensation claims, involve complexities that require realistic assessments and honest communication about potential outcomes.
If your attorney is promising guaranteed victories, substantial settlements, or excessively short timelines without thoroughly evaluating your case, it suggests a lack of integrity and professionalism. These promises may be a tactic to win your trust, but they usually come at the expense of the transparency and caution needed to handle a case effectively.
A good lawyer will provide you with a realistic assessment of your case, including the challenges, timelines, and potential outcomes. If unforeseen issues arise, a good lawyer will communicate these changes transparently, ensuring that you have a clear understanding of the situation.
Trustworthy legal representation involves being upfront about the challenges and guiding you through the process with integrity, rather than offering empty promises.
#8: Your concerns are quickly dismissed
A good workers’ comp lawyer should be a supportive partner in your case. If your lawyer dismisses your concerns about the extent of your injury or your case’s progress without a thorough discussion, it’s definitely a red flag because it can lead to important details being overlooked, which could weaken your case and result in a lower settlement.
Such disregard for your input might imply that your lawyer is more focused on their own agenda than on advocating for your best interests.
Effective legal representation involves listening to your concerns, addressing them thoughtfully, and providing informed guidance. A lawyer who quickly dismisses your questions or worries likely lacks the dedication and empathy required to handle your case properly.
North Carolina Vocational Rehabilitation Benefits
Understand when you may be entitled to vocational rehabilitation benefits after a work injury in Charlotte.
#9: They seem unprepared for hearings
A workers’ comp lawyer who appears unprepared for hearings is a significant concern, as it reflects a lack of diligence and professionalism that could severely impact the outcome of your case.
If your lawyer arrives at hearings unfamiliar with the details of your case or lacks the necessary arguments to effectively represent you, they risk missing critical opportunities to advocate for your rights. This unpreparedness can lead to weak presentations, failure to counter opposing arguments, and an overall inability to leverage the legal process in your favor.
Preparation is key for workers’ comp hearings, and a lawyer who isn’t prepared is putting your case and your future financial security at risk.
#10: They have hidden or unclear fees
Hidden or unclear fees are a big red flag with a workers’ comp lawyer. Workers’ compensation cases are typically handled on a contingency fee basis, meaning the lawyer gets paid a percentage of your final award, and they should be upfront and transparent about the exact percentage and any potential additional costs.
If your lawyer is vague about fees or charges unexpected fees later, it raises concerns about their trustworthiness and potentially puts a bigger dent in your compensation than you anticipated.
Don’t hesitate to ask for a detailed fee breakdown in writing before hiring a workers’ comp lawyer to handle your claim.
Looking for the best workers’ compensation lawyer in Charlotte?
If you’ve talked to a few workers’ comp attorneys and haven’t found the right fit, consider reaching out to the experienced Charlotte work injury attorneys at Wilder Pantazis Law Group.
With over 85 years of combined experience, our team stands out for our deep knowledge, professionalism, and proven success rate in securing favorable outcomes for our clients. We understand the complexities of workers’ compensation cases and are dedicated to providing the personalized attention and strong advocacy you need.